Thursday, January 03, 2008

Looking the Way You Feel

The last time I heard the phrase: “One minute you’re an attractive woman – and the next you’re looking at someone you hardly recognize” was from a woman who was explaining how it is a husband’s fault that the woman they considered attractive when they were dating them is no longer attractive as their wife. The rant had to do with how older women are still attractive, but the problem is that their husbands don’t take the time to properly appreciate them. So, when Connie Poirier started down the road in today’s For Better or For Worse strip about how she has gotten old seemingly overnight without noticing it, it was nice to see that this was not used as an opportunity to slam men.

I would imagine that with the nature of the marital problems Lynn Johnston had last year, dealing with issues about her attractiveness would certainly be a part of it. I view this strip as a very good sign that Lynn has gotten over or dealt with this aspect of divorce, so that issues of attractiveness with respect to men has not even been mentioned in today's strip.

Instead Lynn Johnston is focusing on the differences between your self-image and your real life image. Personally I notice such things less when looking in the mirror, as Connie Poirier describes; because that happens every day, and more from seeing myself in a photograph from an angle I rarely see. The more difficult perception (and I don’t know if Connie is going to head this way in her diatribe) is seeing the way people see your personality and react to it. For example, I went through a period in my life, where I didn’t like giving long and detailed explanations of things, and I simply said, “Yes” or “No” to “Yes or No questions”. Even though I would say these things in a level tone of voice, frequently people would assume I was angry with them, and I learned that longer explanations were necessary, more conversational, and made people feel better about you (even if all those extra words were not necessary to answer the question).

This is even true of comic strip characters. However, Lynn Johnston oftentime circumvents that necessity and relies heavily on a relational shorthand for telling her stories. Today’s strip is the perfect example of that. If I take the strip on its merits, I might simply say, “Real people don’t have conversations like this” or “Photoshopping is not really a method to replace exercise, diet and skin cream, so this joke makes no sense.” However, Lynn depends on her readership looking at the few things being said and relating to them. Any person who has felt younger than they think they looked can say, “That’s the way I feel” and then can feel good about the strip speaking for them. They replace Connie or Elly with their own personality, and therefore Lynn Johnston does not have to write a personality for Connie or Elly except as a generic older woman, who thinks she is unattractive because she is old. The rest of the personality is the reader’s own perspective on what happens to the character.

12 Comments:

Blogger DreadedCandiru2 said...

Which is the real reason peole think that Lynn is telling their stories when what she's really doing is validating them. Seeing something they've done in print in front of them by a character they identify with makes it more real, somehow.

3:58 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Now wouldn't it be great if in the next strip John comes into the room, catches an unexpected glimpse of Elly in the morning light and smiles at her beauty - as he is seeing not the lines, grey hairs etc. - but the woman he still cares for after so many years.

OK - put that down to no coffee yet this morning . . . ha ha

5:13 AM  
Blogger howard said...

dreadedcandiru2,

Seeing something they've done in print in front of them by a character they identify with makes it more real, somehow.

This is the secret of many comic strips. I remember Scott Adams of Dilbert in some interview explaining that the secret of his success was finding an office situation to which working people can relate and then making a strip out of it. Even if the strip wasn't funny or the art wasn't good, people still liked the strip because of that familiarity.

7:35 AM  
Blogger howard said...

Anonymous

Now wouldn't it be great if in the next strip John comes into the room, catches an unexpected glimpse of Elly in the morning light and smiles at her beauty - as he is seeing not the lines, grey hairs etc. - but the woman he still cares for after so many years.

Actually, Anonymous, that would be a nice strip. The last time I can remember John showing any appreciation for Elly was when he had the conversation with Anthony about his wife leaving him and he came home and gave Elly a unexpected hug. There have been far too few of those kinds of strips over the years in For Better or For Worse. In real life though, it wouldn't work, at least judging from my own personal experience of giving compliments to my wife on her appearance. If someone is interested in wallowing in their own unattractiveness, as Connie and Elly are here, anything John said to them to the contrary would be ignored or denied.

7:36 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Excuse me, mind if I squeeze in here?

Howard, I wrote a post for you on my own Journal -- a question -- and I just realized it has recently become buried with other posts. Anyhow, I wanted to bring it to your attention in case you ... missed it.

Forgive me,
Adrianne

8:45 AM  
Blogger DreadedCandiru2 said...

Wallowing in her own unattractiveness, eh? That sounds familiar. That sounds like Liz as a teenager moaning about how nobody likes her because she's ugly, like April complaining about how Becky has clear skin and she doesn't. These women all have severe issues with their appearances that they won't resolve. They don't want the problem fixed or made better as much as they want John to sit there and be miserable with them as a sign that he too agrees how awful things are. Making a problem go away is unfair because that, to them, means that he isn't taking them seriously.

10:52 AM  
Blogger howard said...

dreadedcandiru2,

They don't want the problem fixed or made better as much as they want John to sit there and be miserable with them as a sign that he too agrees how awful things are.
This is an unfortunate aspect of the way Lynn Johnston wrote this, but I am sure this came from her own experience. When I became a father I did read an excellent article talking about the importance of fathers in raising children (i.e. the things fathers bring to parenting which mothers don’t. Sorry, moms). One of the key ingredients was the important part a father plays in giving his daughter self-esteem with respect to her appearance. The idea is that mom can tell the daughter she is pretty until the cows come home, and the daughter will not think anything of it. However, when dad says the daughter is pretty, it builds her self-esteem and most importantly, she does not feel the need to try to get that kind of attention from boys her age, who will tell her she is pretty for more nefarious reasons.

My daughter is only 10 years old, and even at that age, the pressure to be attractive is intense. Nevertheless, I have seen the advice work. She has adorable freckles across her nose, and lovely hair that has naturally differentiating lighter and darker strands like many ladies pay money to get put in her hair. When I tell her how pretty these things make her look, she visibly drinks it in. However, when I compliment my wife on her appearance, those compliments are usually ignored. I expect this difference in perspective (wife vs. daughter) may be the reason why Lynn Johnston has all the Patterson women bemoaning their looks. She is currently the wife and from what we have been told, did not have a good life as a daughter or as a wife.

There have been some moments in the past when John Patterson would look at April and make some observation about her grown-up appearance, where I could tell Lynn Johnston was trying to emulate what she must have remembered Rod Johnston saying about his daughter. Lynn never seemed to be able to get it right without making John Patterson seem a little icky. Possibly this is because she has the wrong perspective on it, or it has been so long since it happened in real life, or maybe Rod Johnston was a little icky when he did it.

11:49 AM  
Blogger DreadedCandiru2 said...

Probably a combiantion of the three. Lynn never probably got complimented too much on her looks so she has sort of the wrong persepctive, it's been years since Katie was a teenager and Rod probably did do so in a way that rubbed her the wrong way.

1:28 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I just today found out that Lynn and Rod Johnston are getting divorced because he ran off with a Lynnion. I feel like I've had my head buried in the sand for the last several months. Wow.

It has totally changed my perspective on the strips that Lynn has drawn since Rod dumped her in April. What previously seemed inexplicable or stupid or an emotional overreaction suddenly makes sense in light of Lynn's personal problems.

I think this strip is Lynn's way of saying she is frustrated that it is pretty unlikely that she will find a real partner in life because:

1. Men die younger than women; by age 60, there are fewer men than women out there.

2. Older men are attractive to a wide variety of women. They frequently marry much younger women. Older women are considered unattractive by most men, young and old. Men who would see her as a good catch beauty-wise are much older and probably infirm.

3. For Lynn, there is the problem of finding a man who is successful/intelligent to be an equal, AND not threatened by her success, AND not attracted by her success/money either.

She is left with very little hope of finding an acceptable partner to share her old age with, while her husband is off cavorting with another woman. I think this probably leaves her feeling very ugly and unwanted.

I get the sense that both Lynn and Rod are jerks, but I kind of feel sorry for Lynn. I have been hating the "Elly is ugly" strips, but now I see where they are coming from.

Also, I hope Lynn finds some sense of resolution over her divorce soon, because I really think it is just helping to run an aging strip even further into the ground, to have her using it to cryptically express her feelings as she goes through the divorce process.

2:57 PM  
Blogger howard said...

qnjones,

Just to get you up-to-date on that sort of gossip, a later report indicated that the Lynnion left Rod and went back to her husband. You are right that it does change the perspective on the strips over the last 4 months. Certainly the reprint strips have not painted John / Rod in the best light, and he is barely a player in the ongoing storylines.

I don’t know that Lynn is interested in finding another man. I would think if she were, then we would see a little more romance in the Anthony / Liz relationship, than seeing the characters already resigned to being together with no love talk (unless you consider “You are a blessing” to be romantic).

My observation has been that it takes awhile to process the end of a long relationship and until that is done, new relationships are likely to suffer. However, if Lynn were to decide to do that, I don’t think it will be that difficult for her. Unlike Elly Patterson, the pictures of Lynn on her website show that she is quite an attractive woman, certainly moreso than a lot of other women her age. I see her biggest problem being item #3 you listed, where she may attract male gold-diggers.

5:19 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Actually, from what I read today, Rod left in April 2007. Since the weekly strips are done 6 weeks in advance, I went and looked at everything from May forward. That's around the time I started to say HUH? about some of the various strips (like the tree falling on the train house), but now they make more sense.

Interesting to hear that the Other Woman went back to her husband. Makes me wonder what the hell they (Rod & Nancy) were thinking.

Regardless of whether Lynn wants a new man or not, it can still feel really lousy to think it's not a possibility anyway. She looks pretty nice in her "posed" photos and average to me in the candids I've seen. I think she heavily Photoshops the ones that go on her website (speaking of today's strip!). But even a very attractive and wealthy 60 year old woman has few prospects.

Now I get why Katie moved home too. I thought before that she must be crazy to do that. But now I wonder if she isn't trying to preserve Lynn's sanity a bit.

6:54 PM  
Blogger howard said...

qnjones,

Now I get why Katie moved home too. I thought before that she must be crazy to do that. But now I wonder if she isn't trying to preserve Lynn's sanity a bit.

Katie arrived on staff in May, 2007 and I noted at the time in The Howard Bunt Blog she replaced Nancy Vincent. aprilp_katje and I wondered what was up at the time, because Nancy’s departure went unheralded by the For Better or For Worse website, which was not the standard for departing long term employees. When Lynn Johnston announced in September that she had filed for divorce back in April, it all made sense. Other things which people have noticed was the fact that John Patterson all but disappeared from the strip for about 4 months around April. And the John-bashing reprints have been a source of amusement over at the FOOBiverse’s Journal since they started in September.

10:54 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home